Book Review: Marley by Jon Clinch
Marley by Jon Clinch
Publisher: Atria Books
Publication Date: October 8, 2019
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Publisher’s Description:
“Marley was dead, to begin with,” Charles Dickens tells us at the beginning of A Christmas Carol. But in Jon Clinch’s “masterly” (The New York Times Book Review) novel, Jacob Marley, business partner to Ebenezer Scrooge, is very much alive: a rapacious and cunning boy who grows up to be a forger, a scoundrel, and the man who will be both the making and the undoing of Scrooge.
They meet as youths in the gloomy confines of Professor Drabb’s Academy for Boys, where Marley begins their twisted friendship by initiating the innocent Scrooge into the art of extortion. Years later, in the dank heart of London, their shared ambition manifests itself in a fledgling shipping empire. Between Marley’s genius for deception and Scrooge’s brilliance with numbers, they amass a considerable fortune of dubious legality, all rooted in a pitiless commitment to the soon-to-be-outlawed slave trade.
As Marley toys with the affections of Scrooge’s sister, Fan, Scrooge falls under the spell of Fan’s best friend, Belle Fairchild. Now, for the first time, Scrooge and Marley find themselves at odds. With their business interests inextricably bound together and instincts for secrecy and greed bred in their very bones, the two men engage in a shadowy war of deception, forged documents, theft, and cold-blooded murder. Marley and Scrooge are destined to clash in an unforgettable reckoning that will echo into the future and set the stage for Marley’s ghostly return.
Most everyone is familiar with Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol. Even if you haven’t actually read the book, you’ve probably seen at least one version in a movie. Marley is a prequel of sorts with the main character being Jacob Marley, Ebenezer Scrooge’s business partner. The book starts when they meet at a boy’s boarding school, where Marley is already bad news. Scrooge is a naïve boy that he takes advantage of without Scrooge even knowing it. Their lopsided relationship continues when they go into business together. Marley makes all the shady business deals while Scrooge handles the books, blissfully (maybe willfully) unaware that most of their business is unseemly at best.
One of the most horrible businesses they are involved in is slavery. When Scrooge becomes engaged to Belle, her father tells him he won’t consent to her marrying him until Scrooge and Marley are divested of the slaving business. Scrooge sets to work on that much to Marley’s consternation. Scrooge is actually a sympathetic character for most of the book. He loves money and accounting but he loves Belle too. It’s Marley that has no redeeming qualities whatsoever.
This book is actually darker and gloomier than A Christmas Carol. A couple of parts are downright horrifying. And that’s what makes it so good. A Christmas Carol is a wonderful book of course, but it’s a spare novel focused on Scrooge and his redemption. Not much is made of the other characters. Luckily for Clinch, there is a lot of room to be imaginative. And he fills in the space wonderfully. Scrooge’s sister Fan and his fiancé Belle are full-fledged characters in their own right. I haven’t read much Dickens but my friends who have tell me that there are Easter eggs related to other Dickens novels throughout. I’m sure they are fun to come across for Dickens fans.
My book club read this book and had mixed reviews as a whole but I really liked it. I was impressed by Clinch’s creativity in crafting Marley and Scrooge’s backstory. Recommended.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
